Challenge by MemorialCare on zoning rejected by federal judge after nearly three-year litigation

By Eric Heinz

San Clemente took a major step toward getting away from the crosshairs of a $42.5 million lawsuit filed by the former owner of the city’s last and only hospital.

Federal Judge David O. Carter issued a ruling on Wednesday, Feb. 6, that stated the city was within its rights to zone the land on which the Saddleback Memorial Medical Center hospital sits as required to provide emergency services and operate as a hospital.

“Because the City’s enactment of (the city’s zoning ordinance) was a legislative zoning decision rather than a quasi-adjudicatory act,” it did not violate the law, Carter stated in his ruling.

Click here to read the full ruling

“The Property at issue is a 6.63-acre parcel that is small enough under California law to be subject to spot zoning,” the federal judge stated.

MemorialCare sued the city after it claimed that the zoning was unfair and that they could not financially support the hospital, which closed in May 2016. They cited a lack of patients and could not provide the services required. They are demanding $42.5 million in retribution, the estimated value of the property.

“However, MemorialCare’s argument that the City provided no evidence that the Zoning Changes would make it more likely that a hospital would remain open on the Property flips the burden of proof,” Carter stated. “Under the applicable standards, MemorialCare has the burden to provide evidence establishing that the Zoning Changes have no relation to the public welfare or are arbitrary and capricious.”

In a press release, the city noted that the judge ruled based on the 15,000 annual emergency room visits the hospital attended, a study that showed mortality rates increase when hospitals close and an Orange County Fire Authority report that state the hospital’s closure would increase “impacts to other hospitals within Orange County and would impact OCFA’s provision of emergency services.”

Emergency medical technicians do not record deaths in an ambulance. People are recorded alive or dead at the scene or at the hospital, experts told the San Clemente Times in 2016, which made it difficult during the closure debate to pinpoint whether a closure would be, empirically, more deadly.

San Clemente Mayor Steve Swartz said he was pleased with the ruling from the court.

“The Court’s ruling supports the City’s position in protecting the public safety of its residents and the greater South Orange County Region by ensuring the property is zoned for a hospital and emergency room,” Swartz stated in a press release on Thursday.

Although the city defended itself on the zoning changes portion of the lawsuit, there’s still the matter of whether MemorialCare will be granted compensation.

“At a minimum, the Zoning Changes keep that possibility open and the Court cannot say that the Zoning Changes will have absolutely no impact on, or are completely unrelated to, the goal of maintaining a running hospital and ER in the City,” Carter stated in his ruling. “However, the impact of the Zoning Changes and the feasibility of maintaining a hospital will likely be litigated in the next phase of trial, when the Court considers, among other things, whether the Zoning Changes deprived MemorialCare of all feasible use of the Property and effected a taking for which just compensation must be paid.”

City attorney Scott Smith said the trial for the monetary compensation is likely to be heard in the next few months. It’s scheduled for Feb. 26 on the court docket, but Smith said extenuating circumstances may cause it to be delayed.

Smith also said he is “really confident” that the city will be successful in defending itself against the multimillion-dollar suit, which alleges an unconstitutional taking of land.

“The test for an unconstitutional taking is deprivation of all reasonable use, and their defense has been that they weren’t making as much money as they’d hoped, but that’s a different measure,” Smith said. “We’re happy to see the council’s action validated.”

Saddleback Memorial Medical Center’s adminstrator Tony Struthers said the hospital provider will address the matter at length at a later day.

“We are reviewing the Judge’s ruling and continue to evaluate all options,” Struthers stated in an email requesting comment from the San Clemente Times.

Editor’s note: This is a developing story. More information will be provided when it becomes available.

About The Author Staff

comments (1)

  • San Clemente needs an ER and a hospital run by leaders that love community service—which is NOT run by Memorial Care! Mission Hospital is more impacted by the closure and the more important issue is: The city of San Clemente is losing precious lives relating to time sensitive emergencies (ie: MI, Stroke, drownings, overdoses).
    Save our SC hospital!❤️

comments (1)

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>