The article you’re about to read is from our reporters doing their important work — investigating, researching, and writing their stories. We want to provide informative and inspirational stories that connect you to the people, issues and opportunities within our community. Journalism requires lots of resources. Today, our business model has been interrupted by the pandemic; the vast majority of our advertisers’ businesses have been impacted. That’s why the SC Times is now turning to you for financial support. Learn more about our new Insider’s program here. Thank you.

By Collin Breaux and Breeana Greenberg

Hundreds of shoes were set out in front of the Capistrano Unified School District offices on Sunday, Nov. 14—an unusual sight for an unusual time.

Parents and families placed the shoes there to symbolize their opposition to a coming vaccine mandate for California students, in which they’ll be required to be fully vaccinated against the COVID-19 virus to attend classes in person.

Parents of district students opposed to Gov. Gavin Newsom’s mandate have been particularly vocal, often showing up at Board of Trustees meetings to denounce the eventual requirement.

The shoes were accompanied by anti-mandate notes that had slogans like “Our children, our choice” and “No shots.” One of the parents who placed shoes at the CUSD headquarters was Amber Smith, one of the founders of Moms on the Ground—a group that recently formed in opposition to the mandate and organizes events through social media.

Smith, a San Clemente resident, said that more than 600 pairs of shoes had been set down over the weekend.

“I went there myself to put two pairs out for my kids,” Smith said. “It’s showing the district, listen, these are the parents that are going to pull their kids out if the mandate goes through.”

She said she is opposed to the mandate because the COVID-19 vaccine hasn’t had any long-term studies on its effects. Smith said she is not anti-vaccine, and her children have received other required vaccinations that have been around longer.

“I’m not going to tell somebody don’t get the vaccine,” Smith said when asked her response to people who say the COVID-19 vaccine is safe and helps prevent the spread of the pandemic. “Some of my family members have been vaccinated. It is my personal choice that me and my family are not vaccinated.”

Smith, who acknowledged she is a not a doctor, said a COVID-19 vaccine should not be mandated for children to get a public education.

Asked if she planned to pull her children from the district if the mandate goes through, Smith said she already pulled her younger daughter out for homeschooling and would also pull her older daughter—who is a senior in high school—if the requirement was implemented before graduation.

The CUSD Board of Trustees recently approved sending a letter to state officials requesting a change in the vaccine requirement, though district officials and staff have repeatedly emphasized they must follow state health guidelines.

“However, most parents were/are not satisfied with this sole step of action from the CUSD school board thus far,” Tania Alward, a South Orange County parent and teacher who’s resided in San Clemente for 34 years, said in an email.

“The large group of parents in attendance that night wanted the CUSD school board to make a public decision for Capistrano Unified School District to not comply with the mandate,” she continued.  “Therefore, like-minded parents are working together to schedule sit-outs/events to peacefully oppose Newsom’s mandate and encourage the Board of Trustees of CUSD to take a stronger stance against the mandate.”

The shoe placing coincided with one such planned school walk-out on Monday, Nov. 15, to further express opposition to the vaccine mandate. A similar walk-out previously happened Oct. 18—when the district saw a 233% increase in absences compared to the week before.

The financial impact to CUSD from the Oct. 18 walk-out is estimated at $500,000, according to the district.

“We are funded based on enrollment,” CUSD spokesperson Ryan Burris said. “If enrollment declines, so does our funding.”

The walk-outs come as CUSD faces a continuing decline in enrollment.

“We are a declining enrollment district so we do expect some decline,” Burris said. “However, this school year and the last we have experienced a decline that is higher than planned.”

During the Oct. 18 walkout, San Clemente’s schools saw the largest increase in absences, with absences up 528% compared to the week before on Oct. 11. The city’s schools have the largest number of students with a total of 8,907 students enrolled.

Dana Point schools saw a 251% increase from the prior week, and San Juan Capistrano schools saw a 233% increase.

Forty-four percent of students enrolled at Palisades Elementary School in Dana Point were absent on the 18th compared to 8.5% on the 11th.

Twenty-three percent of students at Dana Hills High school were absent on the day of the protest compared to 7% a week prior.

Sixty-four percent of students enrolled at Truman Benedict Elementary School in San Clemente were absent on the 18th compared to 10 % on the 11th.

Thirty-nine percent of students enrolled at San Clemente High School were absent on the day of the protest compared to the 7% absent a week prior.

Twenty-seven percent of students at San Juan Elementary school were absent on the 18th compared to the 8% on the 11th.

Eighteen percent of students at San Juan Hills High School were absent on the day of the protest compared to 5% a week prior.

Collin Breaux

Collin Breaux covers San Juan Capistrano and other South Orange County news as the City Editor for The Capistrano Dispatch. Before moving to California, he covered Hurricane Michael, politics and education in Panama City, Florida. He can be reached by email at                         

Breeana Greenberg is the city reporter for the Dana Point Times. She graduated from Chapman University with a bachelor of arts degree in English. Before joining Picket Fence Media, she worked as a freelance reporter with the Laguna Beach Independent. Breeana can be reached by email at

Trustworthy, accurate and reliable local news stories are more important now than ever. Support our newsroom by making a contribution and becoming a subscribing member today.

About The Author Staff

comments (6)

  • Its a parents choice to pull their kids out of school to avoid gettng the vaccine however it will be their kids would suffer the most. School vaccinations are required for other diseases why is the COVID vaccine such an issue? It has been proven safe and effective. Parents who keep kids at home are only hurting their own kids. Its Simply ridiculos. Ask your children after a couple weeks of homeschooling if they are happy with parents as their teachers and I can guarantee they would do almost anything to get back to school.

  • So what you’re saying is these dumb and selfish parents are going to raise even dumber and more selfish children? Because at this point all you’re doing is defunding the district in the most overly entitled way possible. I love how she says “This is MY choice!” Yet she is forcing her kids to go along with it and even trying to deprive the parents of other kids in their district from being allowed to make their choice. A lot of parents are hesitant, but know that the value of education is far more important than the alternative. The only thing she is doing to her younger daughter is depriving her of a decent education, critical thinking skills, and important friendships that foster social skills while relieving stress. Good job mom!

  • This is disgusting. This is an intentional appropriation of the Holocaust. Shoes of Jewish victims were left in piles in Death Camps & have become symbolic of the Holocaust.

    “Exploiting & misusing the tragedy of Jews who were humiliated, marked with a yellow star, isolated in ghettos, dehumanized, and murdered during the Holocaust to argue against vaccination that saves lives is a sad & appalling symptom of moral and intellectual decline.” -@AuschwitzMuseum

  • I am so pleased to hear we have heroes like Amber Smith and Tania Alward standing up for parents’ rights against these foolish mandates. The mandates are just wrong AND they are unnecessary.

  • Shouldn’t you be in Dallas waiting for JFK?

comments (6)

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>