Lee Winocur Field, Ph.D., San Clemente
Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos recently announced that her department will be revisiting the Title IX guidelines on campus sexual assault. The effect of any changes will make it harder to discipline the thousands of students, almost all of them men, who are accused of sexual violence against women each year and return us to the era during which young women were stigmatized for speaking up.
According to Brett Sokolow, executive director of the Association of Title IX Administrators, 10,000 to 12,000 cases of campus rape reach the disciplinary phase every year. Add to that the many cases of reported and unreported sexual harassment, stalking and relationship violence, and it becomes clear that on-campus violence is a critical problem deserving weighty consequences.
But how these cases should be handled is a challenge for any administration. How do schools show support for the survivors while ensuring fairness to both parties? Colleges and universities are in a delicate position, reluctant to dismantle the current system for addressing sexual assault, while anticipating the possible loss of federal funds for not conceding to new guidelines.
Make no mistake, Title IX remains the law of the land. This announcement does not alter in any way schools’ responsibilities. DeVos’ speech noted many situations in which schools have failed to adhere to the law. The response to this challenge is to enforce Title IX more vigorously, not to undermine it.
Now is the time for our local colleges and universities to step up and demonstrate that they will do the right thing for their students even in the midst of potential rollbacks from the Department of Education.
The American Association of University Women together with hundreds of organizations across the country remains committed to protecting and defending Title IX. Students’ access to an education in a safe and secure environment free from the threat of assault is on the line. Schools, and the Department of Education, owe it to all students to uphold their civil rights, a promise Mrs. DeVos’ announcement would most certainly deny.
Title IX is destroying men’s college sports and violating due process
Title IX started out with a noble purpose and has been beneficial to women’s sports on college campuses. However, it has metastasized into something its authors never intended and in 2011, the Obama administration twisted it into a civil rights denying monster. See these videos for examples:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GUvuLuLarr0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Y2AunVKZ-o
The next one is more comprehensive:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w8kfbzcDn3A
And this last one is a little earthy:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BFr169jg3yI
A number of sports on college campuses have been dropped because there are not enough women participating. Wrestling has disappeared from many college campuses, victims of title IX.
Male students accused of sexual assault are penalized, prevented from speaking about the incident, or kicked out of school, all without a trial of any kind; they are not even allowed to defend themselves. This provision, dictated by the Obama administration, has resulted in a number of lawsuits by students against college administrations. It is high time to return title IX back to what it was when it was originally written, a statute meant to provide an even playing field, not destroy men’s sports or worse, destroy their lives with false accusations. We can thank Betsy Devos for doing just that. Outstanding job, Betsy.