The article you’re about to read is from our reporters doing their important work — investigating, researching, and writing their stories. We want to provide informative and inspirational stories that connect you to the people, issues and opportunities within our community. Journalism requires lots of resources. Today, our business model has been interrupted by the pandemic; the vast majority of our advertisers’ businesses have been impacted. That’s why the SC Times is now turning to you for financial support. Learn more about our new Insider’s program here. Thank you.

By Eric Heinz

If 2017 taught San Clemente residents anything it’s that some issues take time to work through.

Mayor Tim Brown spoke with the San Clemente Times prior to the new year about some of the critical issues coming down the pike and some issues that have been outstanding.

“I think, as a community, one of the things that has resonated for me is that I think we need to finish the fight on a lot of the things that we have started,” Brown said. “The first and foremost being the toll road. Now granted, that’s a long-term engagement; however, each landmark, each issue, has to be finished. We have to be thorough and we have to be on-point. And for me, as I look across the breadth of the different things that the city has taken on, from the toll road to the hospital issue, to ongoing litigation…there’s just a myriad of issues.

“Each of those require that the City Council has staying power,” Brown continued. “We really should try to find a conclusion to these as best as we can.”

The Ongoing Toll Road Discussion

The city continues to battle against the Transportation Corridor Agencies (TCA), which operates and administers the toll roads in Orange County. The latest plans for the TCA are to study seven ideas—four of which are toll roads through San Clemente—that officials argue would alleviate traffic congestion in the area. San Clemente’s own representatives on the board have disagreed with this notion.

Brown said some of the plans San Clemente has to rid this impending toll road are tied up in litigation against a protective agreement that was forged between environmental groups and the TCA, which forbids the environmentalists from opposing toll roads through San Clemente in exchange for nixing any plans to build one through Trestles, San Onofre State Park, portions near Camp Pendleton and other areas of South San Clemente. The city is not against the settlement itself, but the protective agreement.

“Outside of the litigation, I think as a city, we really need to build some bridges with some of the other South Orange County cities,” Brown said. “I know we may not see eye-to-eye on this issue, and it’s always a temptation to say, ‘It doesn’t bother us, so we’ll let them deal with it.’ But I do think there’s some common ground we can find with other agencies and other cities.”

Tim Brown was selected as the 2018 mayor of San Clemente. Brown, who was first elected in 2010, is serving his second term as the leader of the city. Photo: Eric Heinz
Tim Brown was selected as the 2018 mayor of San Clemente. Brown, who was first elected in 2010, is serving his second term as the leader of the city. Photo: Eric Heinz

Brown said it’s difficult for San Clemente to plan regional mobility, as its responsibility is to the residents. But he said he didn’t think TCA has all the answers to the problems either.

“I wish the TCA had included us a little more in what their grand designs were,” Brown said. “Now, it feels as if we’re going to be approaching this from different positions.”

 San Clemente’s 90th Birthday

This February marks the 90th birthday since the incorporation of the city of San Clemente, and officials are planning a big bash.
The city will celebrate San Clemente Day during the fourth Saturday of February.

“We’re going to be partnering with all different organizations and hopefully have a great 90th birthday, and something that we can celebrate all year, as we embrace our historical roots and understand all the good work that’s been done before us,” Brown said.

Brown also said he wants the weekend to emphasize the hard work that came into making San Clemente what it is today.
Brown said the schedule of events will be announced in the coming weeks, but some of them will include the San Clemente Historical Society and serving chicken dinners, the first dish served during the inception of San Clemente when people bought deeds to land from Ole Hanson, the founder of the city.

Saddleback Memorial Medical Center Lawsuit

The latest developments in the lawsuit by Saddleback Memorial Medical Center against the city of San Clemente are likely to be heard in January. A hearing was scheduled in December, but was postponed due to counsel scheduling conflicts.

Saddleback Memorial Medical Center in San Clemente was closed after more than 40 years of operation. It was purchased by MemorialCare Medical Group in 2005, but the medical group claimed it was losing more money than it could shore up, as fewer inpatient clients were staying at the hospital. MemorialCare offered to turn the location into advanced urgent care, but the residents of San Clemente were not in favor of that alternative.

If the judge rules in favor of the city’s zoning, then the matter is effectively over. But if the judge rules against the zoning, then it could be determined how much money Saddleback will be entitled. Saddleback demanded a payment of $42.5 million from the city for what its officials viewed as restrictive zoning placed upon it.

Brown said it’s difficult to foresee what the city’s options would be if MemorialCare is awarded its full amount.

“It’s (an amount) that…was meant to have an impact,” Brown said. “I can’t speculate too much of what the outcome of the case will be and what the impacts will be, but as a community we just want what’s best for the health and safety of our residents. We’re hopeful that we’ll have a good outcome, and we’ll do everything we can to avoid that.”

Brown said the city has approached various medical service providers who may want to either construct a hospital with an emergency room or take over existing space, so long as it provides emergency service.

Other Litigation

The city is still working on lawsuits related to short-term living units, signage at the Outlets at San Clemente and some other issues, and Brown said across the board, it’s “not great” for the city to have so many issues at once.

The city increased its legal services spending two-fold between 2015 and 2017, to the tune of more than $2 million.

“We need to defend the city and its ordinances, but at the same time we have to be responsible, and that’s where as a Council and as mayor, I’m hopeful we can find resolutions on those points,” Brown said.

Trustworthy, accurate and reliable local news stories are more important now than ever. Support our newsroom by making a contribution and becoming a subscribing member today.

About The Author Staff

comments (5)

  • I was under the impression that there might be another little issue our community will be facing. Is anyone concerned about the 3.6 million pounds of nuclear waste that Edison will be burying in thin cans within concrete silos 108 feet from the ocean, inches above the water table, in a fault riddled tsunami zone? They will be transferring this highly radioactive material from pools into dry casks for the next year and a half on a daily basis. Bad time for an earthquake not to mention human error or mechanical failure. Meanwhile Edison has no way of dealing with a mishap that could result in a catastrophic release of radiation because they say “there is no plausible way for a criticality event to take place”. These are the same folks who designed replacement steam generators in 2011 that ended up closing the plant 40 years ahead of schedule because their computer modeling was off by 400%. Why doesn’t our mayor want to stand with San Clemente Green and other concerned citizens who think Edison should at least have a remedy in place before attempting the dangerous task of moving fuel into dry storage? What is the hurry? Each canister holds more radiation than was released in the Chernobyl accident in 1986. We have to get it right, (see more here, ). Happy Birthday San Clemente. I hope it’s not your last!

  • Here is another link to see easily understood information about a technical topic that you might otherwise feel intimidated by,

  • I forgot to mention that you can get updates on this most important topic by simply texting SCGreen to 22828. Our group of more than 5,000 diverse citizens is best defined as “Safety Advocates”. Any other label would be too narrow to represent who we are and why we are concerned. Believe me, I’d like nothing more than to think that we are out of danger, but we are not. My motivation is out of concern for you and our community at large. I can’t imagine what motivates others who pretend the threat does not exist. We are in the process of putting together a team of technical and legal experts to arrive at the best solutions for our community. Please consider joining our efforts. I’m happy to answer any questions you may have, or make a group presentation to any interested organization. Thanks, Gary Headrick,

  • defend our ordinances ?? of unfair and fascist laws , like no fence boards left on a truck over night but fence boards are ok on councils cars and vans,,, all other business have to self park to code but not the miramar or del mar ,,,,or the misappropriation of safe walk to school moneys ,,,,,or fancy tiled sidewalks for the privileged owners and areas when many have no sidewalk ???? property rights and fairness and equality are lacking in our community when selective enforcement and subsidization are tolerated ,,, i keep hoping for change how bout you

  • Why is the City up to it’s neck in litigation? Do we have too many lawyers involved in our city governance? I certainly understand litigation around the tollroad, but around the hospital closing? That’s a situation where the city dug a hole and it’s just getting deeper. An urgent care center would be better than NOTHING.

    On the tollroad, the city should have been in front of this issue instead of being caught flat-footed. This is a failure of epic proportions by someone (likely a combination of agencies, government, individuals and more).

    Regarding the signage at the Outlets – here’s a compromise. Have the name changed from “Outlets at San Clemente” to something like “Village Shops at San Clemente.” Other outlets use names that aren’t so down-market (i.e. “The Citadel”).

comments (5)

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>